In the June issue of Atlanta Life, Frank Gaffney of the Center for Security Policy and Alfred Webre of the Institute for Cooperation in Space debated the pressing concerns associated with the United States’ missile defense system based in Central Europe (The New Star Wars, Point-Counterpoint). Gaffney and Webre analyzed the cost, effectiveness and need of the program. In one particularly interesting exchange, the two responded to Russian criticism of the program, which has been significant and lasting.
The United States reached a deal with Poland last week on establishing the missile defense base, with 10 missile interceptors, on Polish territory. Russia has reacted with intensified opposition, and some have speculated that the timing of the deal was meant to reflect American opposition to Russia’s recent military encroaches on Georgia. The deal has far-reaching implications for much of the former Soviet satellite countries, many of whom fear a resurgent Russia. Imparticular, the deal ensures a greater commitment on the part of the United States to defend Poland.
American officials have repeatedly said that the missile defense system is designed to protect against a nuclear-armed Iran, citing evidence that the system would be ineffective against Russian artillery. The Russians, however, have made their distrust clear.
Visit our online archives to read the June Point-Counterpoint debate (pages 12-15). Simply click the magazine cover icon on the homepage.